Employee Benefit Plan Fiduciary Liability Insurance for Growth Enterprises

Virtually every move made by business owners, directors, officers and other "fiduciaries" responsible for employee pension and welfare benefit plans is regulated by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA).  Odds are greater than ever that a business owner will find themselves in court, defending allegations that they somehow breached fiduciary duties. Businesses are especially vulnerable because a sizeable lawsuit or penalty could drive them into bankruptcy.  Employee Benefit Plan Fiduciary Liability Insurance offers business owners a simple and affordable way to protect plan assets and their personal assets.  This insurance provides broad coverage for a wide range of fiduciaries and benefits plans including pension and welfare plans1, qualified and non-qualified plans2, newly created plans and more. Coverage supports business owners' efforts to correct plan defects, thereby preventing fiduciary claims.

Features and Benefits Back To Top
  • Insures certain expenses associated with the Department of Labor's Voluntary Fiduciary Correction Program
  • Covers certain fees and penalties imposed by the IRS or Department of Labor under voluntary compliance programs
  • Extends to delinquent 5500 filer and other penalties as well as UK fines
  • Access to the nation's premier ERISA litigation attorneys to defend claims that arise 
 

When a claim occurs, our goal mirrors that of our customer: To resolve it as quickly and fairly as possible. To achieve this goal, Small Business draws on the our vast claims handling resources, including experienced claims specialists and the nation's premier defense attorneys, who have expertise managing even the most complex, sensitive claims and litigation.

To report an claim, download our claim reporting form and submit it via one of the following methods:

Mail: c-Claim for Financial Lines 
         175 Water Street, 9th Floor
         New York, NY 10038

Fax: 866-227-1750


Claim Scenarios:

Courts Say Don't Wait …
In the case of Barker v. American Mobil Power Corporation, the court held an individual personally liable for losses to a benefit plan while stating that, "While we are not unsympathetic to his burden, we note that fiduciaries may be insured for this type of liability. It would appear that prudent fiduciaries would have their plan or employers secure such insurance."

Repaying 401(k) Losses
An advertising agency owner was ordered by the court to repay more than $120,000 to two 401(k) plans for which he was the trustee. He has also been sued for several thousand dollars more. Among the allegations against him: making improper loans from the plans, failing to collateralize participant loans, failing to secure fidelity bonds for the plans, filing inaccurate 5500s, and failing to value plan assets at fair market value.

Small Plan Creates Large Scale Liability
Two consultants must restore $287,000 to their practice's money purchase pension plan following a suit by the Department of Labor (DOL). The suit alleged that the consultants, who were also the plan's trustees, failed to diversify plan assets, resulting in significant losses to the plan.

Class Action Suit Alleging Breaches Of Fiduciary Duty
A class action suit was filed on behalf of participants in a defined pension benefit plan alleging breaches of fiduciary duty arising out of the conversion of that plan to a cash balance plan. Plaintiffs claimed that inappropriate mortality assumptions and discount rates were used in calculating the lump-sum cash-out values, and that the conversion impermissibly eliminated retirement-type subsidies to save the sponsor money by maximizing the surplus assets in the converted plan. Plaintiffs alleged that the insured's failure to "grandfather" employees with longer service resulted in a decrease in accrued benefits in violation of ERISA, and sued for millions of dollars in damages.